The Magic Oyster is located in the same plaza as “Strawberries Ice Cream” and Sunrise Surf Shop. It is a sister restaurant to Stuart’s Pawnbroker, the Black Marlin and the Palm City Grill.

We were immediately impressed by the “seaside” motif of The Magic Oyster. The ambiance reflects the “island” atmosphere. The prices are reasonable, and the service is quick and friendly.

It is not a very big place but lends itself to intimacy and good food. We enjoyed the fried “Conch” with the tasty pepper sauce. The reasonable “Escargot” is tasty too with several items infused with six mushroom capped escargot.

The folks next to us really enjoyed the “Grouper Reuben” and said it was a “9.5” on a scale of ten. Their New England Claim soup was good too.

The Magic Oyster, though, is most noted for its varieties of oysters. We witnessed several people that came in just to order the oysters. There is already a loyal following.

The Magic Oyster will become a popular place, particularly to the folks who live close by on Hutchinson Island.